Key words blue collar, waitress, intelligence, schooling, work, cognitions, communication, skills discussion intelligence is closely associated with the formal education the type of schooling a person has, how much, and. The professor of education revisits his seminal book, the mind at work, recently released in a 10th anniversary edition. Pdf monograph series representing language use in the. Bluecollar brilliance bluecollar brilliance jobs demand both body and mind. Mike rose reading responses order description you need to get the book blue collar brilliance author. Blue collar brilliance david r miller comp 1 essay 1. Start your 48hour free trial to unlock this shop class as soulcraft study guide and get instant access to the following analysis. Comparing mike roses bluecollar brilliance and david foster.
Essays summer 2009 blue collar brilliance questioning assumptions about intelligence, work, and social class by. Intelligence is closely associated with formal education. Review of bluecollar brilliance rough draft uvu studocu. Blue collar brilliance by mike rose ilanastevelman. Tin only register as at november 1, 2019 department of inland. Mike rose read pages 459469 and answer the question 2,3,4 on page 470. Mike roses blue collar brilliance is a personal essay that begins with his mothers work ethic, leads to her uncles work life and how these two experiences influence his work ethic and how he respects blue collar work. Essay about blue collar brilliance 659 words bartleby. The american scholar is a quarterly magazine dedicated to current events, politics, history, science, culture and the arts.
Analysis of blue collar brilliance 934 words 4 pages. The american scholar, the magazine of the phi beta kappa. Author nisbett talks about a book that believes your iq test score is an accurate measure of someone s intelligence. Rhetorical analysis of blue collar brilliance i chose the article blue collar brilliance by mike rose. The intelligence thats needed for blue collar work needs to be respected in society as people learn that waitresses, kitchen, and service workers can be brilliant, too.
An analysis of bluecollar brilliance, a story by mike. Mike rose, the author of blue collar brilliance, is a professor at ucla and an outspoken contributor on the topics of literacy. Roses essay on blue collar brilliance, mr rose attempts to inform your readers across the different levelsof work theres to get the best educated people for the non educated. Blue collar brilliance mike rose describes in his essay how it was growing up and watching his mother as well as his uncle working a blue collar job, but being very nifty and clever in executing the job.
This article kind of goes against everything i was taught as a child and young adult. I had two jobs under my repertoire and one of them was in a fast food place called del taco. However, there are also many low skilled or unskilled positions, like custodial or assembly line work. A rhetorical comparison manual labor has consumed the life of the common man since time immemorial, which is why modern labor developments seem so strange. He shares with us a number of misconceptions that people have about a liberal arts education. Questions for blue collar brilliance by mike rose by. It comes from the authors family being blue collar workers becoming successful. Though many kinds of physical work dont require a high literacy level, more reading occurs in the blue collar workplace than is generally thought, from manuals and catalogues to work than is generally thought, from manuals and catalogues to work orders and invoices, to lists, labels, and forms.
The article blue collar brilliance by mike rose is aimed at providing an informed insight in regards to the use of intelligence in blue collar jobs. Although i personally went into more detail on roses agreement i also agree with your own argument and understand your side of higher education. Blue collar brilliance by mike rose the personal essay. First this is a new idea and closes with it and second, politics should be kept out this. He himself after finishing college work multiple different teacher jobs before beginning a study about the thought processes involved in blue collar work. Although we rightly acknowledge and amply compensate the play of mind in white collar and professional work, we diminish or erase it in considerations about other endeavorsphysical and service work particularly. I think both book smart and street smart people have pros and cons, but i think street smart people have more of an advantage over book smart people. Blue collar brilliance thesis proposal i help to study. Rose goes an extra mile to dispute the claim and shed light on the assertion that intelligence is acquired through formal schooling and also that white collar jobs are the. Its evident that rose is trying to make the reader see a per. Ungar, he states that during these economic times the field of liberal arts has suffered greatly. He mentions that just because your certain job may have required less time in school, that does not. In the article blue collar brilliance by mike rose, he stresses the point that people who spend more time in school, are not more brilliant than those who do not.
The most common assumption about blue collar jobs is that they require no intelligence and no skill, whatsoever. I really enjoyed reading the essay, it was well written. Bluecollar brilliance introduction to writing uvu studocu. He says there are many common misconceptions about the liberal arts and lists what he believes are the seven biggest misconceptions of today. In this article blue collar brilliance mike rose claims that intelligence is not the standard to divide different occupation and different people. The knowledge and skill they gain is brilliant to the author. The degree of brilliance of a diamond is determ ined by the excellence of its proport ions and the quality of. Comparing mike roses bluecollar brilliance and david foster wallaces kenyon commencement speech. This handout can be used to check for comprehension andor start a discussion about the themes and ideas in the text blue collar brilliance by mike rose. Bluecollar brilliance it is commonly conceived that work requiring less schooling requires less intelligence 247. Not just white collars need intelligence, blue collars also need intelligence.
Questioning assumptions about intelligence, work, and social class. Analysis of the article blue collar brilliance by mike. We are joined by mike rose who is a research professor in the department of education of ucla, california. All three of these authors discuss something that involves with. Blue collar brilliance in blue collar brilliance, mike rose observes his mother, rosie and his mothers brother, joe, in their occupations96. Blue collar brilliance summary author mike rose uses his own life experiences to portray the true value of working a blue collar job. The moves that matter in academic writing with readings. Blue collar brilliance by mike rose talks about how jobs help people learn by using his mother as an example. Blue collar brilliance mike rose by colette ansuini on.
Rhetorical analysis of bluecollar brilliance by mike rose. Motivation factors of blue collar workers verses white. The author closed with idea centered around the government. Many blue collared jobs demand highly skilled workers, such as plumbers, electricians, and plant operators. The only one difference is white collars receive more schooling at college,they make a good use of their education from school,they do their knows. There were a few excerpts from the story that i am able to relate to. Mike grew up with his mother who worked as a waitress at a restaurant, and that was where he spent most of his time silently observing his mother. An analysis of bluecollar brilliance essay 786 words. Ariunjargal badmaanyambuu professor danielle robledo composition and reading march 21, 2019 rose, mike.
In the story blue collar brilliance the author mike rose describes how hard a blue collar job really is through observing his mother work as a waitress and his uncle as a factory worker who made his way up to manager. Some of these include but are not limited to misconceptions, that say a. Roses essay on blue collar brilliance, mr rose tries to tell the reader on the different levelsof work there is for high educated people opposed to the non educated. Motivation factors of blue collar workers verses white collar workers in herzbergs two factors theory elmira h. In blue collar brilliance, mike rose observes his mother, rosie and his mothers brother, joe, in their occupations96. In mike roses essay blue collar brilliance he focuses on the work his mother had to do as a waitress. In his piece of writing bluecollar brilliance, mike rose gives both outcome of clinical study that disagrees with this long held delusion and personal examples. Blaueisenerz n blue iron earth, blue ochre, native. The distinctions among blue, pink, and white collars carry with them attributions of character, motivation, and intelligence.
It was interesting because we are currently living in a society where they make you think that in order to gain knowledge, you need education. In the fourth paragraph, rose writes a waitress acquires knowledge and intuition about the ways and the rhythms of the restaurant business. Blue collar brilliance, author mike rose emphasizes his belief that blue collar jobs should not be viewed as mindless tasks, but rather should be acknowledged for the amount of skills and intelligence these tasks truly require. In the article bluecollar brilliance, the author mike rose thinks that blue collar.
Mike roses bluecollar brilliance is a short story about his mother and uncles work in blue collar jobs. The article bluecollar brilliance by mike rose is aimed. Blue collar brilliance by mike rose this was a particularly interesting article. A blue collar worker is a working class person who performs manual labour. Bluecollar brilliance an educator challenges societys assumptions about intelligence, work, and class by mike rose, from the. Essay about blue collar brilliance 659 words 3 pages blue collar brilliance david r miller comp 1 essay 1 in my observation mentally with mr.
Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Essay examples of an analysis of blue collar brilliance essaybot. Moghaddas california state university east bay, stratford business school abstract herzberg et al. Coined in the early 1920s, a bluecollar professional performs manual labor, often at an hourly wage. Brett clark 12216 summary essay college composition and research liberal arts are not too bad in the article, the new liberal arts written by sanford j ungar, ungar talks about all of the modern misconceptions about the liberal arts degree. Blue collar brilliance and shop class as soulcraft. In the article blue collar brilliance mike rose states that we as a society solely base intelligence on grades and tests but from his various experiences and observations he states that the line of blue collar work can often require more mental activity than they are credited for.
1267 1380 1407 1124 1286 465 1497 389 788 700 309 974 925 445 196 612 1409 747 319 46 864 213 1575 947 998 1408 784 39 526 973 1403 181 1566 542 234 1184 1322 786 1245 211 197 97 933 341 682 786